The Philadelphia Phillies are looking to perform well this offseason as MVP runner-up Kyle Schwarber enters free agency, leaving a significant question mark over the team’s offensive core. Despite Philadelphia putting together an impressive 2025 campaign, the possibility of losing one of their most productive hitters forces the front office to evaluate potential replacements early. With the market expected to be competitive, the Phillies’ decision-making over the coming months will shape both their lineup and long-term trajectory.

Amid that uncertainty, a new prediction points toward a high-profile solution: five-time All-Star Pete Alonso. As teams begin mapping out their offseason strategies, Bleacher Report’s Kerry Miller suggests that the Phillies could turn to the New York Mets slugger if Schwarber departs. Alonso’s power, durability, and defensive versatility position him as one of the few players capable of replicating Schwarber’s on-field impact, making him a logical target should Philadelphia need to pivot.

Pete Alonso Emerges as the Top Predicted Replacement

Bleacher Report’s Kerry Miller identified New York Mets star Pete Alonso as the leading candidate to fill Schwarber’s void should the slugger sign elsewhere. In Miller’s words, “How do you replace one of the four most frequent sources of home runs in all of baseball over the past four years? By signing one of the other members of that quartet, of course.” Miller noted that Alonso’s arrival would also allow the Phillies to shift Bryce Harper back to right field while avoiding the defensive inconsistencies of Nick Castellanos.

Why Pete Alonso Fits Philadelphia Phillies’ Needs

Alonso, a five-time All-Star projected to command a deal worth around $54 million, remains one of MLB’s most consistent power bats. His 2025 season further solidified his value:

Pete Alonso 2025 Stats

Key reasons Alonso fits the Phillies’ offseason strategy:

• Provides immediate power output comparable to Schwarber

• Can play first base, allowing Harper to return to the outfield

• Delivers high RBI production (nearly identical to Schwarber’s levels)

• Offers durable availability, appearing in all 162 games last season

With the Mets possibly entering a transitional phase, the door could open for Philadelphia to capitalize.

Philadelphia Phillies’ Offseason Outlook

While the idea of losing Kyle Schwarber isn’t ideal for Philadelphia Phillies’ front office or fanbase, alternative options matter, especially in an offseason expected to include aggressive bidding across the league. Miller emphasized that Schwarber staying is the most likely scenario, but exploring fallback plans is simply smart baseball business.

Phillies’ Two Potential Paths

The Phillies’ ability to keep their roster stable hinges largely on Schwarber’s free agency decision. If he stays, the offseason becomes simpler. If he walks, Alonso represents a high-value option who could stabilize the lineup without sacrificing production.

Also read: MLB trade rumors: New York Mets potentially eyeing $13.25 million Kansas City Royals’ Ace to bolster rotation ahead of deadline

For Philadelphia, securing a long-term solution, whether Schwarber or Alonso, will determine how the franchise moves forward in its pursuit of another deep postseason run.